Best AeroGarden Alternatives: LetPot, Ahopegarden and Click and Grow Compared

By Sarah WhitfieldUpdated 16 min readResearched, not tested
Three unbranded countertop hydroponic gardens growing basil and lettuce under built-in lights
On this page14 sections
  1. The Best AeroGarden Alternatives at a Glance
  2. Key takeaways
  3. What Makes a Good AeroGarden Alternative
  4. The Alternatives Side by Side
  5. LetPot LPH-Air: Closest AeroGarden Swap
  6. Ahopegarden 10-Pod: Budget Pick
  7. LetPot LPH-SE: More Plants
  8. Click and Grow Smart Garden 3: Silent
  9. LetPot LPH-Max: Most Automation
  10. When to Stay With AeroGarden
  11. The Cheapest Alternative: Kratky Jars
  12. Which Should You Buy?
  13. One Last Tip
  14. Frequently Asked Questions

Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Urban Hydro Space earns a small commission on purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Three unbranded countertop hydroponic gardens growing basil and lettuce under built-in lights

Researched, not tested: every product in this post was chosen from the makers’ published specifications, labels and listings, not tried at home. How we research and choose products.

The best AeroGarden alternatives do what an AeroGarden does, a countertop garden with its own light, a timer and a small reservoir, for less money, with more pods, or with an app that sets the light from your phone. A lot of people went shopping for one when AeroGarden said it would close at the start of 2025. It came back that spring. By then, though, the rest of the market had caught up, and a few of these gardens are good.

The standard AeroGarden Harvest is the yardstick here, as the most common starter garden. None of the five gardens below has been tried at home, so each is judged on the specs that decide whether a countertop garden works in a small kitchen. That means how many plants it really holds, how tall they can get, and how much water it carries. Then there’s the light: do you set it, or does the factory? The cheapest option comes last, and it has no light or pump at all. Not sure you want a countertop garden yet? Read is an AeroGarden worth it first, and the apartment hydroponics beginner’s guide if you want to know how any of these systems works.

Is AeroGarden still in business? Yes. In late 2024 the brand announced it would close at the start of 2025, then it relaunched in spring 2025. Scotts Miracle-Gro says AeroGarden is still part of the ScottsMiracle-Gro family, with gardens and seed pod kits on sale again. So you don’t need an alternative because AeroGarden vanished. You might want one for the price, the pod count or the app.

The Best AeroGarden Alternatives at a Glance

Match the garden to how many plants you want and how much say you want over the light. Specs are the makers’ own.

LetPot LPH-Air (10 pods) on Amazon

Closest AeroGarden swap: LetPot LPH-Air (10 pods)
Research pick.

  • Fits: a kitchen counter, with 10 pods, a 4 liter tank and a 24 W light that rises to 14 inches.
  • Control: set any light schedule in the app, so you can run the 14 hours most herbs want.
  • Skip if: you want no app at all, or plants taller than 14 inches.

Check price on Amazon $69.51

Add it to my Amazon cart

Ahopegarden 10-Pod Garden on Amazon

Budget, no app: Ahopegarden 10-Pod Garden
Research pick.

  • Fits: 10 pods, a light post that rises to 14.5 inches and a window to check the water level.
  • Control: it only offers a built-in 16 hours on, 8 off cycle, with two light modes.
  • Skip if: you want to set your own hours, because the cycle is fixed.

Check price on Amazon $65.99

Add it to my Amazon cart

LetPot LPH-SE (12 pods) on Amazon

More plants: LetPot LPH-SE (12 pods)
Research pick.

  • Fits: 12 pods and a 5.5 liter tank, so it goes longer between top-offs than the Air.
  • Control: the same app and 24 W light as the Air, in a stainless steel shell.
  • Skip if: counter space is tight; the plastic LPH-Lite has the same pods and tank for less.

Check price on Amazon $119.97

Add it to my Amazon cart

Click and Grow Smart Garden 3 on Amazon

Silent, no pump: Click and Grow Smart Garden 3
Research pick.

  • Fits: a desk or windowsill, with 3 pods fed by wicks, so there is no pump to hum.
  • Control: fully automatic light, and a full tank lasts about 2 to 3 weeks, per the maker.
  • Skip if: you want more than three plants, or to use your own seeds and nutrients.

Check price on Amazon $124.95

Add it to my Amazon cart

LetPot LPH-Max (21 pods) on Amazon

Most automation: LetPot LPH-Max (21 pods)
Research pick.

  • Fits: 21 pods, a 7.5 liter tank and a 36 W light that rises to 30 inches.
  • Control: the maker says it tops up water and nutrients by itself from a level sensor.
  • Skip if: you have a small kitchen, or want to keep the cost down.

Check price on Amazon $251.99

Add it to my Amazon cart

Whichever you pick, I’d give herbs and greens about 14 hours of light a day and change the water every 2 weeks. Prices are pulled from Amazon and were last checked on 18 November 2026 at 8:47 am. Amazon prices change often, so check the listing before buying.

Key takeaways

  • AeroGarden is back in business since spring 2025, so an alternative is about price, pod count or features, not about the brand disappearing.
  • Pod count is not plant count. Big herbs such as basil fill two or three pods’ worth of space, so a 10-pod garden grows about five or six full plants.
  • The tallest the light can go decides what you can grow: about 12 to 14 inches suits herbs and lettuce, while tomatoes need far more.
  • An app with a free light schedule lets you run the 14 hours a day that suits herbs, while fixed cycles run 16, a poor fit for spinach and cilantro.
  • If you don’t need a gadget, two Kratky jars and a small light grow more for less, and there’s nothing to break.

What Makes a Good AeroGarden Alternative

A hand raising the light post on a countertop hydroponic garden above tall basil plants.

In photos, every countertop garden looks the same. So compare them on the specs that actually change what you can grow.

  • Real plant count. The pod number on the box is the number of holes. Basil, mint and other bushy herbs each want the space of two or three pods once they are grown, so plan on filling about half the holes with big plants. The best herbs for small hydroponic systems shows which stay compact.
  • Light height. The highest the light can rise is the tallest your plants can get. For example, around 12 to 14 inches suits herbs and lettuce. Fruiting crops need much more room, which is why only the largest gardens claim them.
  • Tank size. A bigger tank means fewer top-offs and steadier water, because small volumes swing faster. A small tank under a full deck of herbs can drop low within days in a warm kitchen.
  • Light control. Herbs and greens do best on 14 hours on, 10 off. So an app or timer that lets you choose the hours is worth having, because a fixed 16 hour cycle cannot be set to 14, and spinach and cilantro both tend to bolt under 16 hours of light.

Two more things matter once you’ve owned one for a while. First, what does it run on? Gardens that take plain grow sponges and baskets let you use any seed and any bottled nutrient, while gardens built around their own pre-seeded pods keep you buying the brand’s refills. Second, noise. Most use a small pump to move the water, and only the wick-fed ones are silent. For the premium end of the market, my AeroGarden vs Gardyn vs Click and Grow comparison goes deeper.

The Alternatives Side by Side

Every figure below comes from the maker’s listing or product page, checked in October 2026. When a maker doesn’t publish a figure, the table says so instead of guessing. Garden names in the table link to Amazon (paid links).

GardenPodsLightTallest lightTankLight control
AeroGarden Harvest Lite (for reference)6LED, wattage not listedPlants up to 12 inNot listedBuilt-in on/off timer
LetPot LPH-Air1024 W, two modes14 in4 LApp, any schedule
Ahopegarden 10-Pod10Full spectrum, two modes14.5 inNot listed16 on, 8 off, cannot be set
LetPot LPH-SE1224 W, two modesNot listed5.5 LApp, any schedule
LetPot LPH-Lite1224 W, two modes16 in rod5.5 LApp, any schedule
Click and Grow Smart Garden 33LED, extends as plants growNot listedLasts about 2 to 3 weeks16 on, 8 off, cannot be set
LetPot LPH-Max2136 W, eight brightness levels30 in7.5 LApp, auto water and feed

Prices move a lot, so check the live price on each listing. Roughly, the LetPot Air and the Ahopegarden are the budget picks, the SE and the Click and Grow sit in the middle, and the Max is a splurge.

LetPot LPH-Air: Closest AeroGarden Swap

LetPot LPH-Air ten pod countertop hydroponic garden with an adjustable LED light bar

The Air is the closest thing to a Harvest with more room. It takes 10 pods instead of 6, holds 4 liters, and its 24 W light rises to 14 inches, a little higher than the Harvest Lite’s 12. LetPot lists a pump, a touchpad and an app that sets the light anywhere from 0 to 24 hours, plus two light modes, one for leaves and one for flowering.

The app is why it’s my top pick. You choose the hours, so herbs and greens can get the 14 on, 10 off I recommend instead of a fixed cycle. One thing from the listing: the sponges in the box come without seeds. I actually like that, because you grow what you want. Just order seeds before the garden arrives.

Watch for: 10 pods means about five or six grown basil plants, not ten, and a 14 inch ceiling rules out anything tall. The four numbers every countertop system runs on apply here too.

Check the LetPot Air on Amazon $69.51

Add it to my Amazon cart

Ahopegarden 10-Pod: Budget Pick

Ahopegarden ten pod indoor hydroponic garden with a height adjustable light post and water level window

The Ahopegarden is the simplest way into a 10-pod garden. There’s no app. You plug it in, and it runs a preset cycle of 16 hours on and 8 off that you can’t change. It also has two light modes, one for vegetables and one for flowers and fruit. The light post rises to 14.5 inches, and a window on the side shows the water level, which helps more than it sounds when you can’t see into the tank.

The catch is that you can’t bring it down to the 14 hours I’d want for herbs and greens. I’d leave spinach and cilantro out of this one, since 16 hours of light pushes both toward bolting.

Watch for: Ahopegarden does not list the tank size, so check the water window often in the first week, and run the garden for a few days while you can still return it.

Check the Ahopegarden on Amazon $65.99

Add it to my Amazon cart

LetPot LPH-SE: More Plants

LetPot LPH-SE twelve pod stainless steel countertop hydroponic garden

If the Air feels small, the SE adds two pods and a much bigger 5.5 liter tank, with the same 24 W light and app. The tank is the real upgrade, because a full deck of grown herbs drinks a small reservoir down fast. Topping off hydroponic water explains why the level matters. LetPot also puts sponges, baskets, covers and A and B nutrients in the box. You pay extra for the stainless steel shell.

If you do not care about the steel finish, the LetPot LPH-Lite $89.99 has the same 12 pods, 5.5 liter tank and 24 W light in a plastic body, and LetPot lists its light rod at 16 inches.

Check the LetPot SE on Amazon $119.97

Add it to my Amazon cart

Click and Grow Smart Garden 3: Silent

Click and Grow Smart Garden 3 with three basil pods under its built-in grow light

The Smart Garden 3 works differently. There’s no pump: wicks draw water up into each pod, so it makes no sound at all, and Click and Grow says a full tank lasts about 2 to 3 weeks. The light runs a preset cycle of 16 hours on and 8 off, and although you can’t change it, the light does extend as plants grow. Each pod comes pre-seeded with nutrients built in, so there’s nothing to mix.

That convenience is also the catch. You get three plants, from the brand’s own pods, and you can’t just drop in your own seeds and a bottle of nutrients. I’d put it on a desk or in a bedroom, where a humming pump would bother you more than a small harvest. It’s also one of the three systems in my best countertop hydroponic systems roundup.

Check the Smart Garden 3 on Amazon $124.95

Add it to my Amazon cart

LetPot LPH-Max: Most Automation

LetPot LPH-Max twenty one pod smart hydroponic garden with a tall extendable light

The Max is the big one: 21 pods, a 7.5 liter tank and a 36 W light with eight brightness levels on a rod that extends to 30 inches. LetPot says it’s the first system to top up both water and nutrients by itself from a water level sensor. Of everything here, it asks the least of you.

That 30 inch light is what opens the door to taller crops. Plan for the space, though: it’s a countertop garden in name, and a large one. And self-dosing still has to be refilled from somewhere, so I’d check the solution with a meter now and then instead of trusting it blind. A good pH meter keeps any automated garden honest.

Check the LetPot Max on Amazon $251.99

Add it to my Amazon cart

When to Stay With AeroGarden

An alternative isn’t automatically better. AeroGarden has the longest track record in the category, its seed pod kits are on sale again, and spare parts are still easy to find. If yours still runs, keep it. A garden that works beats a new one with more holes in the lid. When an AeroGarden does act up, it’s usually the setup rather than the hardware, and the AeroGarden guide covers the common fixes. Torn between a LetPot and an AeroGarden of the same size? The LetPot vs AeroGarden comparison matches the two lines up from entry level to the largest models.

You don’t have to keep buying its pods, either. Replacing AeroGarden pods with your own seeds and nutrients shows how to run any of these gardens, AeroGarden included, on ordinary seed and bottled feed. If you’re buying new and like the brand, the AeroGarden Harvest Lite $57.99 is the current entry model. Whatever you buy, run it for a few days while you can still return it, and keep the box and receipt.

The Cheapest Alternative: Kratky Jars

Two black-sleeved Kratky jars of basil and lettuce under a clip-on grow light

If you want fresh herbs rather than an appliance, the cheapest alternative to any countertop garden is a couple of wide-mouth jars with Kratky lids and a small grow light. Since there’s no pump, nothing can break, and there’s no app to update. Each jar also holds one plant and its own water, so one problem never spreads to the rest.

This is the setup I’d steer most beginners toward. A quart jar is on the tight side for a basil or mint plant, while a gallon carries a lettuce to harvest. The Kratky jar setup guide walks through it, the net cups and lids guide compares the parts, and the grow lights under $50 cover the light. The trade-off: you mix nutrients and check pH yourself, which a countertop garden partly does for you.

Which Should You Buy?

Pick by the one thing that matters most to you:

  • An AeroGarden-style garden with more room and a free schedule: the LetPot LPH-Air.
  • A budget pick with no app: the Ahopegarden 10-Pod.
  • A dozen plants and fewer top-offs: the LetPot LPH-SE, or the cheaper LPH-Lite.
  • Silence on a desk or nightstand: the Click and Grow Smart Garden 3.
  • The most hands-off garden, if you have the space: the LetPot LPH-Max.
  • Herbs rather than a gadget: two Kratky jars and a small light.

Whichever you choose, the basics don’t change. Keep the pH at 5.5 to 6.5 and give herbs and greens about 14 hours of light. Then top off with plain pH-adjusted water between changes, and change it all every 2 weeks. How often to change hydroponic water explains that routine, and the pH and nutrient calculator gives the feed for your tank size. The seed to harvest calculator tells you when the first basil or lettuce will be ready, and the running cost calculator works out what any of these gardens costs a month in power, nutrients and pods. Buying one as a present? The gift guide for indoor herb growers has smaller ideas too.

Where these facts come from

Pods, light wattage, light height and tank sizes come from each maker’s Amazon listing, read in October 2026, and from LetPot’s own LPH-Air product page for the Air’s 14 inch light and 4 liter tank. AeroGarden’s status comes from Scotts Miracle-Gro’s announcement and Bob Vila’s report on the relaunch (March 2025). The 14 hour light schedule, pH range and 2 week water change are this site’s standard settings, and the bolting risk for spinach and cilantro under 16 hours comes from this site’s crop table.

Power is a small part of the cost, but it differs between models. The countertop garden electricity cost study lists a year of electricity for 24 countertop gardens, including the LetPot, Ahopegarden and Click and Grow models compared here.

One Last Tip

Look at the light height before the pod count. Every garden on this list grows basil, but the moment a basil plant touches the light it stops being fun and becomes a pruning chore. How often that happens comes down to one spec: how high the light can go. I’d take a 10-pod garden with a 14 inch ceiling and a few big plants spaced out over a 12-pod garden crammed full, every time. That way, you’ll spend your evenings harvesting instead of fighting for room under the lamp.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is comparable to an AeroGarden?

I’d point most people to the LetPot LPH-Air. It’s the closest match, with 10 pods, a 4 liter tank, a 24 W light that rises to 14 inches and an app for the light schedule. The Ahopegarden 10-Pod costs less, though its 16 hour light cycle cannot be set, and Click and Grow suits anyone who wants a silent garden with no pump.

Is AeroGarden still in business?

Yes. AeroGarden announced in late 2024 that it would close at the start of 2025, then relaunched in spring 2025. Scotts Miracle-Gro says the brand is still part of the company, and its gardens and seed pod kits are on sale again. So buying an alternative is a choice now, not a necessity.

What is a cheaper alternative to AeroGarden?

The Ahopegarden 10-Pod and the LetPot LPH-Air both sit at the budget end, and both hold more pods than an AeroGarden Harvest. Cheaper still is a pair of Kratky jars under a small grow light. There’s no pump or app, and each jar grows one basil or lettuce plant.

Can I use my own seeds in an AeroGarden alternative?

In most of them, yes. LetPot and Ahopegarden gardens take grow sponges and baskets, so any seed and bottled nutrient works, and the LetPot Air even ships without seeds. Click and Grow is the exception, since it’s built around its own pre-seeded pods with the nutrients inside.

How many plants does a 10-pod garden really grow?

About five or six full-size herbs. Once they’re grown, bushy plants such as basil and mint each spread over two or three pods’ worth of space, so I’d fill only about half the holes with big plants. Small herbs and lettuce can use more of them.

Do I need an app-controlled garden?

No, but I’d want one. An app or adjustable timer lets you run herbs and greens on 14 hours of light a day, the schedule this site recommends. Gardens with a fixed cycle usually run 16 hours, which cannot be set to 14 and is a poor fit for spinach and cilantro.

Which countertop garden is the quietest?

The Click and Grow Smart Garden 3, because wicks move the water and there’s no pump at all. Most other countertop gardens use a small pump that hums quietly. A Kratky jar is silent too, since it has no pump or power.

Can these gardens grow tomatoes?

Only the tall ones. A light that rises 12 to 14 inches suits herbs and lettuce, not tomato plants. Of the gardens here, only the LetPot LPH-Max has room for small fruiting crops, thanks to its 30 inch light, and even then I’d pick a compact variety.

How often do you change the water in a countertop garden?

Top off with plain pH-adjusted water whenever the level drops, then change the whole tank every 2 weeks. A bigger tank, such as the 5.5 liter LetPot SE, needs topping off less often than a small one under a full deck of plants.

What is the best AeroGarden alternative?

For most kitchens, I’d pick the LetPot LPH-Air: 10 pods, a 4 liter tank, a 14 inch light and an app that sets any schedule, at a budget price. Choose the Ahopegarden 10-Pod to skip the app, the LetPot SE for more plants, or Click and Grow for silence.

Ask a question or leave a note

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *